David Stubbs reviews What’s the Story (Morning Glory), 30th September 1995

July 2, 2009

David Stubbs reviews What's the Story Morning Glory, 30th September 1995

David Stubbs reviews What’s the Story (Morning Glory), 30th September 1995.

A very generous review from Stubbs. I was never a big fan of Definite Maybe but this record was a fucking disgrace after that and the fact that it sold by the truckload was the most depressing thing that happened in 1995.

Bookmark and Share

7 Responses to “David Stubbs reviews What’s the Story (Morning Glory), 30th September 1995”

  1. Of course, the way the music press instantly decided that this was The Album Of A Generation – mere weeks after their mostly rather dismissive original reviews – was the definitive moment when they lost their authority and credibility (actually, perhaps it wasn’t, perhaps *the* definitive moment was when they did the opposite over ‘Be Here Now’, a masterpiece one week, overblown dreck the next).

    It also remains the moment a certain subculture died, and perhaps so did British politics, in their true sense.

  2. […] only fair to remember that there was always a counter-argument – in 1995 we find David Stubbs declaring Oasis finished, and this was even before they’d played that show to a crowd of 16 million or […]

  3. nick Says:

    I cant believe people are bagging out morning glory the album is great and most importantly original. people may say that oasis steal from the beatles etc. however it is important to realise the beatles had their influences aswell. tracks such as champagne supernova, wonderwall and even morning glory are timeless classics. Noel Gallagher is considered music legend. If you dont believe it simply listen to the bands b-sides such as talk tonight and the masterplan. Oasis, live forever!

  4. It’s a fine pop album. Retro and derivative, maybe, but great songwriting. It just became too big, in the sense that everyone in the country should own a copy or they were weren’t “normal.” You wouldn’t be saying this if Oasis had called it quits after this or even Be Here Now.

  5. albert Says:

    What an asshole the reviewer is!
    I can’t believe what i just read. This is an all-time classic album, one of the greatest albums ever, and not just because I am saying it or because I believe so, but because It has sold millions and milliosn of copies, and this album and this band has influenced many of amazing bands (Travis, Kasabian, Jet, Arctic Monkeys, Glasvegas and many more that I forgot)

    They failed with “Don’t Look Back In Anger”? My god, what the hell this man has in his head? IT’S A CLASSIC THAT STANDS THE TEST OF TIME. It’s almost the national anthem of the UK…

    My god, I am angry as fuck…

  6. […] Other Opinions Are Available.  What did this people have to say about (What’s the Story) Morning Glory? Rolling Stone Consequence of Sound Archived Music Press […]

  7. […] “Una cosa es que el sol de la mañana te ilumine con la inspiración; otra es quedarse dormido en la hamaca o simplemente sudar en el calor. En otras palabras, (What’s The Story)… es ocasionalmente sublime pero a menudo laborioso y flojo. En esta evidencia, Oasis es una banda limitada … Muchos momentos, pero demasiados cuartos de una hora en el medio. Oasis están caídos, faltos de estrellas. Suenan destrozados” – Melody Marker […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: